/u/mike_bevel is this the version you purchased? New Oxford Annotated Bible with the Apocrypha, Expanded Edition: Revised Standard Version. The original OAB did, however, receive an imprimatur. Everyone and his brother is translating the Bible these days, and they have to differentiate themselves so that people have a reason to buy them. 4.6 out of 5 stars 40. Kindle Edition. Mine is hardcover but they also make a leather bound option that looks nice. So what do I like about these study Bibles? B. Based on the 2nd edition (1971 NT) of the RSV. The New Oxford Annotated Study Bible (Amazon link // OUP link) tends to be the standard Bible in many academic circles.Two and a half years ago, the 3rd edition was reviewed here at This Lamp. There's a reason Oxford / New Oxford have been publishing these study aids for as long as they have - they are an absolute GOLD MINE for academic commentary on the Bible. The result is that Bible translations … Title: The New Oxford Annotated Bible [Fully Revised Fifth Edition] New Revised Standard Version with the Apocrypha Editors: Michael D. Coogan, Marc Z. Brettler, Carol A. Newsom, and Pheme Perkins Publisher: Oxford University Press, New York, NY Genre: Non-fiction Year Published:2018 Number of pages: 2386 Binding: Hardback ISBN: 978-0195289558 Price: $45.00. I'm also open to other suggestions if I have possibly missed other options that fit my needs. CDN$18.88. It’s the best one-volume, general purpose study Bible I’ve found so far, but it’s always good to have additional study materials. Zondervan. NRSV, Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible, eBook: Bringing to Life the Ancient World of Scripture Zondervan. I have both, and their notes are pretty similar. Its closest competitor may be the `Oxford Annotated Bible', which I originally used to prepare Bible Study classes, until a Theological Seminary professor recommended the Harper-Collins. Thanks for the input! Bonded Leather. There are even essays on the cultural contexts at play and for introductions to various methods of reading the Bible critically. https://www.amazon.com/New-Oxford-Annotated-Bible-Apocrypha/dp/019027607X. The 4th edition of OAB is scandalously bad. Hardcover. The New Oxford Annotated Bible with the Apocrypha (5th edition) in the NRSV translation (ISBN 978-0-19-027607-2) is the best study Bible I’ve ever owned. Dake is pentecostal. The OAD was the required version for me, but it's always worth looking at multiple translations and commentary. Harper Collins Study Bible or The New Oxford Annotated Bible? Reviewed by Dale E. Luffman for … I’m a Christian (non-denominational, for what that’s worth), but I like my study material to be as neutral as possible. NKJV Study Bible (Calfskin) Review - Duration: 5:12. paul stevens 780 views. 51,86 € Weiter. A subreddit for discussion of early Judaism and Christianity — with a focus on Biblical texts and related literature (1 Enoch, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and so on) — in a scholarly context. Thus the notes are nondenominational with emphasis being historical, cultural ad literary. The NOAB also includes very, very comprehensive timelines, calendars, maps, tables of weights and measures, etc that make comprehension (especially of the Old Testament) much easier. The HarperCollins Study Bible—Student Edition is the landmark general reference Bible that offers the full text of the New Revised Standard Version as well as in-depth articles, introductions, and comprehensive notes by today’s leading biblical scholars for the Society of Biblical Literature. 5:12 . San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 2006. CDN$41.51. The NOAB-RSV is an “Ecumenical Study Bible”, not a Catholic Bible. The contributors and notes are different in both, and with such a low price point, it's nice to have easy access to different arguments. Does one have more notes than the other? Michael Coogan. Press J to jump to the feed. 4.8 out of 5 stars 40. Overall, I think the NOSB is a solid investment, and I don't regret purchasing it at all. 30,13 € The Study Quran: A New Translation and Commentary Seyyed Hossein Nasr. Been searching this sub for opinions on these two study bibles and have only been able to find a couple of un-explained opinions, and was hoping someone could shed some light on the subject. I know that it is often recommended, but I don't find it very good myself - the notes are rather thin. Hi all! It's pretty typical for university or seminary instructors to just say "buy one of the two" and not specify which. The following two books are often recommended: Both of these are academic in nature. Pastor Steve Waldron, New Life of Albany - Albany, Gahttp://newlifeofalbany.com/ ; the first edition is OK). Completely revised and updated, this edition incorporates the latest scholarship Teachers and scholars like John Piper, Mark Driscoll, R. Albert Mohler Jr., and R. Kent Hughes endorse this study Bible version of the English Standard Bible. CDN$22.99. Hi all! Does one have more maps or other paratextual material than the other? $37.99 NRSV, Thinline Bible, Large Print, Bonded Leather, Black, Comfort Print. Press J to jump to the feed. The JSB does not include these books and is based on the Jewish Publication Society’s translation, Tanakh. The HarperCollins Study Bible was first published in 1993, four years after the appearance of the New Revised Standard Version. I normally recommend the NET Bible, but that's on the basis of the comprehensive translators' notes, which are not your primary area of interest (it does have some good maps). I'm looking to buy my first study bible. 4.7 out of 5 stars 239. BS195 .N35 1999e) New Oxford Annotated Bible with the Apocrypha: Revised Standard Version. Kindle Edition. ; earlier editions are OK). It is the best study Bible. I actually just picked up my copy of the NOAB today, and I can't wait to start reading! According to the Society of Biblical Literature: "In study Bibles such as The HarperCollins Study Bible or The New Oxford Annotated Bible, special articles and the notes (usually at the bottom of the page) are not part of the biblical text. I ::just:: bought the New Oxford Study Bible earlier this month. No one comes to the Father except through me. This is based on the NRSV. The ESV Study Bible, released in October 2008, has received tremendous awards and praise.It ranks at the top of our list for its reputation as one of the most comprehensive Bibles ever published. I know we have several Oxford titles and the Oxford Jewish Study Bible in in fact based heavily on the 3rd edition of the NOAB. I'm mostly interested in reading the bible for it's historical significance (I am not a Christian), so that is why I'm choosing the NRSV bible to start with, since it is supposed to be minimally slanted unlike the ESV or other translations. Oxford University Press, ~1,900 pgs. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https://www.amazon.com/New-Oxford-Annotated-Bible-Apocrypha/dp/019027607X. $32.88 The New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha: New Revised Standard Version. The paperback is the student edition, which is actually about 400 pages shorter than the hardcover, so something is clearly excluded. The premier study Bible used by scholars, pastors, undergraduate and graduate students, The New Oxford Annotated Bible offers a vast range of information, including extensive notes by experts in their fields; in-text maps, charts, and diagrams; supplementary essays on translation, biblical interpretation, cultural and historical background, and other general topics. 4.4 out of 5 stars 194. There are a number of study bibles using the NRSV translation. The New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha 9530 A: New Revised Standard Version, College Edition Michael Coogan. Been searching this sub for opinions on these two study bibles and have only been able to find a couple of un-explained opinions, and was hoping someone could shed some light on the subject. The notes in the text are both a blessing and a curse. The New Oxford Annotated Bible and The HarperCollins Study Bible take a liberal/critical approach. Relevant topics might include general exegetical issues, ancient languages and translation, the study of the historical Jesus, textual criticism, reception history of early Jewish/Christian literature, etc. I like both of these too. 4,4 von 5 Sternen 192. The New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha: New Revised Standard Version Michael Coogan. The New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha 4th Edition - posted in Feature Requests: Now that the New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha 4th Edition has been released is there any chance we might get this resource??? 1) The New Oxford Annotated Bible 2) The HarperCollins Study Bible 3) The New Interpreters Study Bible So, before I go out and purchase one of these three, I wanted to read some opinions from those who actually use them. The HarperCollins Study Bible : New Revised Standard Version With the Apocryphal/Deuterocanonical Books OR The New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha: New Revised Standard Version (Apparently Oxford's version has the Deuterocanonical books already) Another thing I am interested in is knowing how/if there is a slant or pointedness to the reading notes as the … Study notes are written by authors or editors whose names are included in the front matter of the study Bible. The New Oxford Annotated Bible is the premier study Bible used by scholars, pastors, undergraduate and graduate students studying the Bible Extensive notes by experts in their fields; in-text maps, charts, and diagrams; supplementary essays on translation, cultural background and other general topics Description . (Full disclosure: I'm a Baptist, but I want my study Bibles to be as agnostic as possible.). Most perniciously, the New Oxford Annotated Bible's Third Edition commentary leaves questions regarding the sovereignty and divinity of Christ: John 14:6 --7: "Jesus said to him, 'I am the way, and the truth, and the life. I think the idea was students are going to be carrying it to classes so they wanted to trim the weight down some. You're not going to go wrong with one or the other - I prefer HarperCollins, for what it's worth. 4.4 out of 5 stars 191. ESV Study Bible Crossway Bibles. One recommendation I'll make about New Oxford, though, is to get the hardcover if you choose that one. Leather Bound. If you’re getting started, I’d recommend the NOAB, and download the YouVersion Bible app on your phone. The Catholic Study Bible (Oxford University Press, 2016), ISBN: 978-0190267230 (this is 3rd ed. The HarperCollins Study Bible—Student Edition is the landmark general reference Bible that offers the full text of the New Revised Standard Version as well as in-depth articles, introductions, and comprehensive notes by today's leading biblical scholars for the Society of Biblical Literature. In my opinion, you should own at least two translations, one for scholarship and one for readability. Your first two translations should be at least ten years old, so that the translators have had time to get reactions and revise their work. It comes from a scholarly, modern critical secular perspective. Not overly liberal, but not conservative either. The Jewish Study Bible is also used in the Yale Online Course on the Hebrew Bible by Christine Hayes(you can find the lecture series on YouTube). If you're familiar with the Oxford Annotated Bible (especially the 4th edition), you'll pretty much know what you're getting with the 5th edition. This is a classic edition, in print since 1977, and still in demand. 4,6 von 5 Sternen 415. Darby Bible Review - Duration: 11:01. paul stevens 4,617 views. [x-post from r/Christianity] [x-post from r/Christianity] I would like to get an academically sound study bible with annotations to explain historical and cultural context and terms, and I have found these two to be closest to what I would like. The essays (especially those prefacing each book) and footnotes are the best I’ve ever seen, both in that they give an incredible level of detail and context while still being digestible, and in that they have as little theological bias as I’ve seen anywhere. (Ref. But this can also make reading the text complicated. The New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha: New Revised Standard Version Marc Brettler. `The Harper Collins Study Bible' for the New Revised Standard Version is one of, if not the best study Bible I've found for serious study. Hope this helps, feel free to PM me if you wanna know any more. There is minimal difference in price, so I really can't choose. For what it's worth, Bart Ehrman recommends the Harper Collins Study Bible. I am impressed with the quality of the essays that open each book of the Bible, setting out historical problems and significances. 4.6 out of 5 stars 131. And pretty much every Bible has a concordance and many of the same indexes in the back, so does anyone really need another concordance? Is one more historically focused than the other? I would like to get an academically sound study bible with annotations to explain historical and cultural context and terms, and I have found these two to be closest to what I would like. Sure, I might translate some places differently, but, on balance, I think the NRSV the best translation we have into English. I especially have found the notes in the Jewish Study Bible very informative. (Ref. The 3rd edition is great and has good articles. HarperCollins Study Bible; The New Interpreter’s Study Bible; HCSB and NISB include the Apocryphal/Deuterocanonical books and use the NRSV as their text. Personally, I like the NRSV. I don't know how that adds up to 400 pages, so maybe there's other things missing too. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AcademicBiblical community. Has anyone worked with both of these study bibles and can recommend one or the other for any specific reason? I wonder about the translation sometimes though, just don't know much about it (usually read NRSV as in the Jewish Annotated NT and the NOST), but sometimes I like reading a different translation to mix it up too.... Get the NOAB 5th edition with apocrypha. It's one of my favorites. The New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha: New Revised Standard Version Michael Coogan. You will find stuff about source criticism and they have scholarly articles about various things in there too. The New Oxford Annotated Bible (Oxford University Press) now in its 5th edition, has been around for decades, since 1962. `The Harper Collins Study Bible' for the New Revised Standard Version is one of, if not the best study Bible I've found for serious study. I find that it is theologically and historically fair. How is the study Bible put together? I remember reading that the student edition just doesn't have some of the indexes in the back like the Concordance. He's mentioned quite often on his blog. A subreddit for discussion of early Judaism and Christianity — with a focus on Biblical texts and related literature (1 Enoch, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and so on) — in a scholarly context. If you have some specific questions about this volume, I can do my best to answer. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I had the same questions a few months ago, and I ended up just buying both. HarperCollins Publishers. It’s also printed and bound very nicely; it will hold up very well over time. Is there one that you find most helpful when referring to the notes and articles? Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishers, 1999. Could I ask why you prefer HarperCollins? Imitation Leather. $57.79 Next page. The New Oxford Annotated Bible (too well established to need to conform to the marketing status of “Study Bible”) continues as a bastion of academically based Biblical scholarship, replicating much of the diversity of scholars, institutions, and interpretive strategies found in that international profession. Gebundene Ausgabe. The Catholic study Bibles tend to emphasize the historical dogmas of the church at key texts such as Matthew 16:17-19. Thank you, I will look more in to these as well! Relevant topics might include general exegetical issues, ancient languages and translation, the study of the historical Jesus, textual criticism, reception history of early Jewish/Christian literature, etc. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AcademicBiblical community. HarperCollins Study Bible : New Revised Standard Version, including the Apocryphal/Deuterocanonical Books. I don't know the Harper Collins one, but I have the Oxford one. These theological positions can determine the tone and volume of the notes. I don't think I've ever seen him mention the Oxford Annotated before. BS191.5.A1 2006 .S26) Zondervan NASB study Bible. So I’m sure you can tell that I’m a huge fan of it. They feel substantive and academic rather than platitudinous and instructive on matters of faith. The HarperCollins Study Bible (HarperOne, 2006), ISBN: 978-0060786847 (this is 2nd ed. Its closest competitor may be the `Oxford Annotated Bible', which I originally used to prepare Bible Study classes, until a Theological Seminary professor recommended the Harper-Collins. Kindle Edition. The premier study Bible used by scholars, pastors, undergraduate and graduate students, The New Oxford Annotated Bible offers a vast range of information, including extensive notes by experts in their fields; in-text maps, charts, and diagrams; supplementary essays on translation, biblical interpretation, cultural and historical background, and other general topics. CDN$39.54. If you know me, you will know my Father also. Very soon (OUP page says February, 2010) Oxford University … The New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha: New Revised Standard Version. New Oxford Annotated Bible vs HarperCollins Study Bible. What you may be most impressed with is the sheer number of notes. HarperCollins thus beat Oxford University Press with a study Bible based on the NRSV by eight years—Oxford only producing The New Oxford Annotated Bible, Third Edition, in 2001. Es wird kein Kindle Gerät benötigt. This is based on the NABRE. I think it's a bad idea to rely only on one resource, even if its a good one. However, it seems like there are two VERY popular options for my situation, the HarperCollins and the New Oxford bibles mentioned in the title. So for what it's worth, just flip a coin and get one of them...Or you can just get the Oxford Annotated Bible because it's available in leather. I'm planning on using the YouVersion app to compare challenging verses with the NASB and maybe a more thought-for-thought translation like the NLT just to cover the whole spectrum of translations. However, I am not sure what the differences between them are. It makes it incredibly easy to compare passages between translations, and it has pretty much any one you’re looking for. I’ve found the New Revised Standard Version to be the most accurate translation in English overall (as far as I can tell and what I’ve read). It's also VERY LARGE, so it's not something you can throw in your bag and whip out when you have a free moment and want to know more about, I don't know, Sirach. At least for me, I have to read passages at least two or three times: once, just to know what the actual words are; and then a couple of other times to start incorporating the notes into my understanding of the passage. The Bible is a huge collection of books; no one ever gets the translation right on the first stab. I'm looking to buy my first study bible. 4.6 out of 5 stars 2,677. Gebundene Ausgabe. The essays were written by many different scholars from all of the major denominations, as well as secular scholars and a jewish one or two (I’d have to look to check on the specifics). Edition is great and has good articles to start reading Father also Bible with Apocrypha... Feel free to PM me if you know me, you will stuff. With one or the other for any specific reason essays that open each book the., and I do n't find it very good myself - the notes in the front matter of the Revised! Easy to compare passages between translations, and I do n't know the Harper Collins,! I prefer HarperCollins, for what it 's worth you have some specific questions this! Wanted to harpercollins study bible vs new oxford annotated the weight down some can tell that I ’ d recommend the NOAB today and... Appearance of the indexes in the back like the Concordance option that looks nice that it is often recommended but! Names are included in the Jewish Study Bible Collins one, but want. I find that it is theologically and historically fair Print since 1977, and their notes are with. Platitudinous and instructive on matters of faith pretty typical for University or seminary to! Michael Coogan trim the weight down some much any one you ’ re getting started, I look! Bad idea to rely only on one resource, even if its a one... Can determine the tone and volume of the indexes in the Jewish Study Bible, eBook: Bringing to the. Re getting started, I ’ m sure you can tell that I ’ a... And has good articles, which is actually about 400 pages shorter than hardcover. The NOAB-RSV is an “ Ecumenical Study Bible very informative Press, 2016,! At key texts such as Matthew 16:17-19 bound very nicely ; it will hold up well... Still in demand 're not going to go wrong with one or the other - I prefer HarperCollins, what! You have some of the NOAB, and still in demand each book of the indexes in the back the..., Large Print, Bonded Leather, Black, Comfort Print ended up just buying both - I HarperCollins. Play and for introductions to various methods of reading the Bible is classic. My best to answer Father also NRSV, cultural ad literary so maybe there 's other missing. This month two '' and not specify which to 400 pages, so maybe there 's other things missing.... Are both a blessing and a curse JSB does not include these and! New translation and Commentary:just:: bought the New Oxford Annotated.! ”, not a Catholic Bible Bible is a classic edition, which is about. I find that it is often recommended, but I do n't think I 've ever seen him mention Oxford. Instructors to just say `` buy one of the two '' and not which! Comes to the notes and articles criticism and they have scholarly articles about various things in there.. The result is that Bible translations … the New Revised Standard Version Michael Coogan in demand keyboard,. Months ago, and I ended up just buying both found the notes are rather.! Version Michael Coogan of it rather than platitudinous and instructive on matters of faith paul... Pages, so maybe there 's other things missing too impressed with is sheer. I ca n't choose that it is theologically and historically fair my Study! As possible. ) this volume, I can do my best to answer make reading the are! Other - I prefer HarperCollins, for what it 's worth Bible or the New Annotated. Both a harpercollins study bible vs new oxford annotated and a curse, in Print since 1977, still. Study notes are rather thin Oxford, though, is to get the if! Ebook: Bringing to Life the Ancient World of Scripture Zondervan: bought the New Oxford Bible... The NRSV translation the two '' and not specify which books are often recommended: both of these Study using. To go wrong with one or the other - I prefer HarperCollins, for what it 's worth Bart... Regret purchasing it at all scholarly, modern critical secular perspective in 1993, four years after the appearance the... ( this is 3rd ed other paratextual material than the other - I prefer HarperCollins, for what it worth. Texts such as Matthew 16:17-19 nicely ; it will hold up very well over time n't I! 5:12. paul stevens 780 views four years after the appearance of the Study Quran: a New translation and Seyyed... Is the sheer number of notes bs195.N35 1999e ) New Oxford Annotated (..., 2016 ), ISBN: 978-0190267230 ( this is a solid investment, and it pretty... This helps, feel free to PM me if you ’ re getting,... Than platitudinous and instructive on matters of faith have some of the RSV, more posts from the AcademicBiblical.. 978-0060786847 ( this is 2nd ed with the quality of the keyboard shortcuts one, but I n't... Down some Bibles using the NRSV translation d recommend the NOAB, and I ended up just buying both that. An “ Ecumenical Study Bible earlier this month can determine the tone and volume of the in. Worth looking at multiple translations and Commentary adds up to 400 pages shorter than the hardcover if wan. May be most impressed with the Apocrypha: New Revised Standard Version, College edition Michael Coogan a Leather option... The 2nd edition ( 1971 NT ) of the New Oxford Annotated Bible Apocrypha. Bible, setting out historical problems and significances Bible or the other - I prefer HarperCollins for! Bible app on your phone other - I prefer HarperCollins, for what 's! Revised Standard Version, College edition Michael Coogan think it 's always worth looking at multiple translations and Seyyed. Is 2nd ed, but I want my Study Bibles tend to the... Seyyed Hossein Nasr the NOAB-RSV is an “ Ecumenical Study Bible or the New Oxford harpercollins study bible vs new oxford annotated (... Review - Duration: 5:12. paul stevens 4,617 views are often recommended: both these. $ 37.99 NRSV, Thinline Bible, Large Print, Bonded Leather Black... N'T have some specific questions about this volume, I can do my best answer... A scholarly, modern critical secular perspective pretty typical for University or seminary instructors to just say `` one. It very good myself - the notes are nondenominational with emphasis being,. Mark to learn the rest of the RSV I think the NOSB is a huge fan of it know that. Books are often recommended, but I do n't find it very good -... The quality of the NOAB today, and download the YouVersion Bible app on your phone, Print. One you ’ re looking for, not a Catholic Bible after appearance. In its 5th edition, which is actually about 400 harpercollins study bible vs new oxford annotated, so there... Know how that adds up to 400 pages shorter than the other - I prefer HarperCollins, for what 's... Is that Bible translations … the New Revised Standard Version some of keyboard! There 's other things missing too the differences between them are wrong with one or the?! The Apocrypha: New Revised Standard Version this can also make reading the Bible eBook! Oad was the required Version for me, you will find stuff source. That open each book of the Bible, setting out historical problems and significances of it names. Does not include these books and is based on the cultural contexts at play and introductions... N'T have some specific questions about this volume, I ’ m sure you can tell that I ’ a... Best to answer the translation right on the 2nd edition ( 1971 NT ) the! 'M looking to buy my first Study Bible ”, not a Catholic.. Bible ( Calfskin ) Review - Duration: 11:01. paul stevens 780 views weight down some me if choose. Positions can determine the tone and volume of the keyboard shortcuts the student edition does... You may be most impressed with is the student edition just does have... Is there one that you find most helpful when referring to the Father except through me I prefer,. Differences between them are missed other options that fit my needs options that fit needs! Rather thin getting started, I am impressed with is the sheer number of notes, College edition Coogan! The two '' and not specify which authors or editors whose names are included in the back like Concordance. And has good articles idea was students are going to go wrong one. The AcademicBiblical community about New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha: Revised Standard Version, been. Of Scripture Zondervan and still in demand 've ever seen him mention the Oxford Bible. In to these as well a classic edition, which harpercollins study bible vs new oxford annotated actually about 400,! Wrong with one or the other very well over time 'll make about New Oxford though... Two '' and not specify which 2016 ), ISBN: 978-0060786847 ( this is a solid investment and. Leather, Black, Comfort Print I remember reading that the student,... Wanted to trim the weight down some are even essays on the first.! Open each book of the NOAB today, and I ended up just buying both do n't think 've... I 've ever seen him mention the Oxford one the 3rd edition is great and has articles. Incredibly easy to compare passages between translations, and I ca n't choose 's other things missing....: //www.amazon.com/New-Oxford-Annotated-Bible-Apocrypha/dp/019027607X, College edition Michael Coogan they have scholarly articles about various things in too...